Recently, Rolling Stone’s “The 50 Greatest Video Games of All Time” has been making the round on the Internet. While I wouldn’t associate Rolling Stone with video games (and if I’m being completely honest, I didn’t even know it was still a thing), I find that I always enjoy perusing these lists.
Looking at Rolling Stone’s top 10:
1. ‘The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild’ (2017)
2. ‘Tetris’ (1989)
3. ‘Grand Theft Auto V’ (2013)
4. ‘Super Mario World’ (1991)
5. ‘The Last of Us’ (2013)
6. ‘Half-Life 2’ (2004)
7. ‘Metal Gear Solid’ (1998)
8. ‘Final Fantasy VII’ (1997)
9. ‘The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim’ (2011)
10. ‘Super Metroid’ (1994)
It had many of the games I would expect to see there: Breath of the Wild, Tetris, Super Mario World, The Last of Us, and Metal Gear Solid appear regularly in lists like this. What struck me though is how few of the games on the list I had actually played. In the top 10, I had only played four of the games. Expanding to the whole list, I have only played 18 of the games.
In some ways, that isn’t too surprising. It has only been during the past few years that I owned a contemporary console. Before that, I was content at replaying a handful of my personal classics. My most commonly played titles were the various 2D Castlevania and Super Mario titles, Turtles in Time, and Sid Meier’s Pirates!.
When I read lists like this, I always like seeing how my personal favorites rank. I think that is because I tend to view video games — like music — as being highly subjective. Sure, there are objective technical criteria that can be used to judge some things like graphics, but at it’s core, I think what one likes in game is quite personal.
For example, when reflecting on Rolling Stone’s list, I would never put Breath of the Wild near the top. I can recognize that it was innovative in terms of open world design and the freedom to explore, but I ultimately preferred the 2D Zelda games. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past did make it on the list, but at the low position of 47. It was one of only two series to have multiple titles on the list. Another favorite of mine — Castlevania: Symphony of the Night — also was near the bottom. I probably would have placed both in the top 10.
Ultimately, I think lists like this are just interesting thought experiments.


Leave a Reply